Skip to content
McMillan Insurance Agency

Contact Your Carrier

Choose your carrier below for claims and customer service. Your policy documents also list your carrier’s current claims contact.

American Modern

American Modern

Claims Phone Number: 800-375-2075

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

AmTrust

AmTrust

Claims Phone Number: 866-272-9267

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Bristol West

Bristol West

Claims Phone Number: 800-274-7865

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Encompass

Encompass

Claims Phone Number: 800-588-7400

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Foremost

Foremost

Claims Phone Number: 800-527-3907

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Grange Insurance

Grange Insurance

Claims Phone Number: 800-445-3030

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

National General

National General

Claims Phone Number: 888-233-4575

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Nationwide

Nationwide

Claims Phone Number: 800-421-3535

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Openly

Openly

Claims Phone Number: 857-990-9080

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Plymouth Rock Assurance

Plymouth Rock Assurance

Claims Phone Number: 888-324-1620

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Progressive

Progressive

Claims Phone Number: 800-776-4737

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Safeco

Safeco

Claims Phone Number: 800-332-3226

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

State Auto

State Auto

Claims Phone Number: 888-504-4527

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

The Farmers Fire Insurance Company

The Farmers Fire Insurance Company

Claims Phone Number: 800-537-0928

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Travelers Insurance

Travelers Insurance

Claims Phone Number: 800-252-4633

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

Universal Property

Universal Property

Claims Phone Number: 800-470-0599

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website

USLI

USLI

Claims Phone Number: 800-523-5545

Claims Website: Visit Website

Customer Service Website: Visit Website