What to know

The Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers reported an average commercial auto premium increase of 6.7% in Q3 2026. That is market context, not a prediction for your policy. Review changes in your operation and coverage alongside the price.

What the latest survey says

A headline about falling business insurance prices can be frustrating when your commercial auto renewal arrives with an increase. Different lines of insurance do not necessarily move together.

In its Q3 2026 market survey, published November 16, the Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers reported an average commercial auto premium increase of 6.7%. Its average change across all account sizes was a decrease of 1.3%. The reporting period was July through September 2026.

Those figures describe survey respondents’ experience across a market. They do not establish what a particular contractor, delivery business or trucking operation should pay. Treat them as a reason to examine your renewal carefully, rather than as a target increase to accept or reject.

Claims costs remain part of the explanation

Verisk’s September 2026 commercial auto analysis, covering data through Q1 2026, reported that claim severity for its latest four quarters was approximately $29,000, up 10% from the preceding four quarters. Severity describes the average cost per claim in the report; it does not describe how often claims occur.

This helps explain why fewer accidents and lower insurance prices do not always arrive together. If the accidents that do occur cost more, pressure on premiums can remain. Industry data is useful background, but your agent still needs to explain the terms being offered to your business.

Separate a price change from a change in the business

Before deciding whether a renewal is competitive, place the expiring policy and renewal proposal side by side. Ask the agent to identify which differences reflect changes in your operation, which reflect coverage changes, and which the carrier attributes to pricing.

Illustrative example

A fleet grows from three vans to four.

The annual premium rises, but so does the number of vehicles insured. A comparison of the two total premiums will not isolate the change in pricing. Ask for an explanation that accounts for the added vehicle and any other changes in coverage or use.

Give the agent a current vehicle and driver list, a description of the work you perform, and any changes in mileage or operating territory. If a document is missing, identify who will obtain it and when. An organized submission makes the comparison easier to interpret.

Questions worth asking before you renew

  • What changed in the terms? Compare limits, deductibles, exclusions, endorsements and payment arrangements.
  • Does the proposal describe our current operation? Check vehicles, drivers, garaging and the work each vehicle performs.
  • Are the alternatives comparable? Ask the agent to identify coverage differences alongside each price.
  • What would a higher deductible mean for our cash flow? Decide what the business could comfortably pay after a loss before selecting one.
  • What does the carrier need to evaluate us accurately? Request a specific document list and a review timeline.

Keep a written record of the answers. The useful outcome of a renewal review is a decision you can explain: the terms selected, the cost, and any obligations the business needs to meet.

For a McMillan review, have your current policy and renewal proposal available. Call 717-850-0503 to discuss your operation and the questions you want answered.

About this article

Sources checked November 17, 2026. This article provides general information. Coverage and eligibility depend on policy terms, carrier requirements and the circumstances. Ask your agent about your specific operation.

← Back to Blogs